I still think the third gen will win, but I'm biased...
a charger with big 22" rims and low profile tires cannot be expected to hook at the track like it would (if it even does) on the street. Not to mention all the electronic garbage thats will slow the car down if it does start to spin...Assuming that charger is untuned..
Yea I know you can turn traction control off or whatever dodge calls it, but it wont be completely off if they are still using the benz technology (wouldnt suprise me) unless the driver knows how to get the car in dyno mode, which is an outside chance.
So basically if the guy wiht the thirdgen can launch correctly and maintain the lead, which shouldnt be too difficult, i think he can win.